Sunday, November 22, 2026Panama City

Nexo Capital

Legislation · Markets · Investment
Política Fiscal

The Court rejects a challenge to the confidentiality rule of a Foreign Ministry committee

The Full Court found the alleged violation against Article 56 of Executive Decree 368 of 2018 insufficiently argued; exclusion for breaching confidentiality remains in force, without a ruling on the merits.

A person in a black Legislat T-shirt waits on the sidewalk across from the Judicial Branch building; nearby, a document box on a planter and a black cat among the plants.
Illustrative image generated with AI.
By Redacción Nexo Capital · Mesa Editorial · November 7, 2026, 14:15

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Justice declined to admit the unconstitutionality complaint against part of Article 56 of Executive Decree No. 368 of August 17, 2018, which issues the Internal Regulations of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MIRE) and implements Title II of Law 28 of July 7, 1999. The decision, dated July 27, 2026 and drafted by Justice Maribel Cornejo Batista, became final on September 2, 2026. A lawyer filed the action on his own behalf.

Article 56 provides that matters and documents submitted to the Qualifying Committee are confidential and that its members must keep absolute secrecy. The challenged part provides that breaching that obligation results in exclusion from the Committee, without prejudice to any applicable administrative and criminal liability.

The plaintiff invoked Articles 4, 17, 18, 32 and item 14 of Article 184 of the Constitution. He argued that the exclusion operates automatically, without a hearing or procedure, contrary to Article 8 of the American Convention on Human Rights; that a regulatory provision cannot impose that sanction; that the provision does not identify the authority competent to determine the breach; and that the decree created a sanctioning regime the law did not authorize.

The Court found that the complaint met the formal requirements of Articles 101, 2559, 2560 and 2561 of the Judicial Code, except for the explanation of the alleged violation required by item 2 of Article 2560. For the Full Court, the arguments were subjective opinions and criticisms of a provision that merely attaches a consequence to the breach of a prohibition. It cited its ruling of March 15, 2021, docket 13308-2021, which requires reasons that are clear, certain, specific, pertinent and sufficient.

In practice, the confidentiality rule and its exclusion sanction continue to apply in the MIRE Qualifying Committee. For lawyers who litigate constitutional matters, the decision restates the level of argument the Full Court usually requires to admit a complaint against a regulation.

A refusal to admit is not a declaration of constitutionality. The debate over procedural guarantees in that exclusion could return to the Court with a better-argued complaint or be settled through an amendment of the regulations by the Executive Branch, although no such initiative is on record so far.

Nexo Capital will follow any new action or reform concerning the regime of the MIRE Qualifying Committee.

Research assisted by Sentinel, with editorial verification of official sources. Discover Legislat.ai

← Back to front page