Supreme Court backs governors refusing to review evictions decided by community justice courts
The full Court upheld the denial of the amparo filed by Kerdin Ocean Corp. against the Panama Governor's Office, which summarily rejected an extraordinary appeal in an eviction case.

The full Supreme Court of Justice upheld the decision of the Superior Court of the First Judicial District that denied the constitutional amparo filed by Kerdin Ocean Corp. against Resolution R.A.-003-2025 of November 27, 2025, issued by the Governor's Office of the Province of Panama. The ruling is dated September 29, 2026 (case 80619-2026) and became final on October 30.
The case stems from a foreclosure proceeding brought by Banco Universal, now Canal Bank, S.A., and from an eviction of an intruder ordered in 2021 by the Community Peace Justice House of the San Francisco district and confirmed in 2022 by the Enforcement and Appeals Commission, with the eviction already carried out. The company later went to the Governor's Office with an extraordinary administrative review appeal, based on a Public Registry certificate stating that the bank was not the owner of the property when it sued. The Governor's Office summarily rejected it.
The Court explains that Article 39 of Law 16 of 2016 was replaced by Article 44 of Law 467 of 2025, which keeps the rule that the Appeals Commission's decision is final and not subject to appeal; it therefore rules out a retroactive application of the law or a breach of due process under Article 32 of the Constitution. It adds that deciding whether the Governor's Office should have examined the ground of newly discovered evidence under Article 166 of Law 38 of 2000 is a matter of ordinary legality, outside the scope of amparo.
For banks, owners and real estate investors, the ruling reinforces the finality of intruder evictions handled by community peace justice: once the appeal is exhausted, review before the governor cannot reopen them. For occupants and defendants, the reading is the reverse: registry documents would need to be submitted in the original proceeding, because afterwards the room for correction in the administrative route narrows and amparo cannot be used to discuss the evidence.
The ruling does not address ownership of the property or other judicial avenues the company might pursue. Nexo Capital will follow case law on Law 467 of 2025 and community peace justice.
Research assisted by Sentinel, with editorial verification of official sources. Discover Legislat.ai