Sunday, November 22, 2026Panama City

Nexo Capital

Legislation · Markets · Investment
Política Fiscal

The Court rejects a challenge to the dependence of tax courts on the Revenue Directorate

The Full Court found the argument against three phrases of Articles 316 and 320 of Law 76 of 2019 insufficient; the first instance for tax appeals remains within the General Revenue Directorate.

Judicial Branch building with its sign on the facade; in the foreground, a grey folder and a calculator on a granite bench, and a black cat among the plants.
Illustrative image generated with AI.
By Redacción Nexo Capital · Mesa Editorial · November 4, 2026, 10:39

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Justice declined to admit the unconstitutionality complaint against three phrases of Law 76 of February 13, 2019, which approves the Tax Procedure Code. The decision, dated August 14, 2026 and drafted by Justice Ariadne Maribel García Angulo, became final on September 10, 2026. The action had been filed by a lawyer on his own behalf.

The challenged phrases are «adscritos a la dirección general de ingresos» (attached to the General Revenue Directorate) and «mediante facultad delegada por el director general de ingresos» (through powers delegated by the Director General of Revenue), in item 1 of Article 316, and «por el director general de ingresos» (by the Director General of Revenue), in the first paragraph of Article 320. According to the complaint, those expressions place the administrative tax courts within the organic, functional and disciplinary structure of the General Revenue Directorate (DGI), the same entity whose acts they review, and leave the tenure of judges and clerks in the hands of its director. These courts decide, at first instance, requests for reconsideration against DGI acts.

The plaintiff invoked Articles 4, 17, 18, 19, 20, 32, 41, 201, 202, 210 and 215 of the Constitution and Articles 8 and 25 of the American Convention on Human Rights. The Court concluded that the explanation of the alleged violation, required by item 2 of Article 2560 of the Judicial Code, rested on subjective views about how those courts should be organized rather than on an analysis of the conflict between the phrases and the Constitution. It added that Articles 201, 202 and 210 govern the Judicial Branch, while Law 76 governs the tax system, so they do not match the challenged phrases.

For taxpayers, the practical consequence is that the current scheme stays in place: anyone contesting a DGI act first files for reconsideration before courts attached to that directorate; afterwards they can appeal to the Administrative Tax Tribunal and go to the contentious-administrative courts. The complaint argued that those later avenues do not cure the lack of independence at first instance.

A refusal to admit is not a declaration of constitutionality. The debate over the independence of the tax courts could return to the Court with a better-argued complaint or reach the National Assembly through an amendment to the Tax Procedure Code, although no such initiative is on record so far.

Nexo Capital will follow any new action or reform proposal concerning the first instance for tax disputes.

Research assisted by Sentinel, with editorial verification of official sources. Discover Legislat.ai

← Back to front page